Blog

Feb 23rd

I Want the Whipped Cream – Again!

Posted by with 4 Comments

To the students in Dr. Bailey’s class.  Give your kids the whipped cream!

It’s case conference time – oh no.   A necessary evil to ensure legally that my disabled child receives the services she needs in the public school system.  But wait! Stop!  I want you to think differently this year.  I want you to take control of your child’s education, but in a way you may have never considered.  How did I rid my fear of case conferences and my child’s academic future?…..You may be surprised when I tell you….  but I want to share with you the freedom to let go and set your teachers free.

My purpose for starting this blog was based on a discomfort brewing in me regarding the role the government plays in the lives of families and their loved ones with disabilities.  The disability community, in my opinion, has been taken over by the government.  Having served for the last three governors in the state of Indiana, and representing tens of thousands of families with loved ones with disabilities, I fully understand the importance of good public policy and the necessity of granting rights to people who often cannot speak up for themselves.

The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act  (IDEA) was necessary to allow young children to go to public school who had disabilities. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) was necessary in order to make public entities accessible to people with physical and mental limitations.  Both were necessary – but where do we go from there?  Because, we seem to be stuck in a pattern.

What I walked away with from my tenure with the state, is that public policy only ensures us the minimum, and unfortunately, that’s all we often receive (think public housing, food stamps, etc.). We get the bare minimum of what some good intentioned advocate can muster to pass through legislation.  And that good intentioned advocate used to be me, so I know what I am talking about.

Remember, if the service is actually good, our legislators will undoubtedly cut back funds in order to spread the money among an unending list of new requests. The government “unfunds” the good, and tolerates the intolerable.  So I ask you… how much more would you get if we didn’t have policies, that due to the nature of the system,  limit a lot of the good things your child could receive?

Sure, I will SETTLE for a plain chocolate sundae if that’s all you tell me I can have, but wouldn’t it be all the better with whipped cream?   I mean…. where’s the whipped cream, where’s the nuts, the HOT FUDGE?  Somehow, we have diminished our kids’ educations down to IEP’s, case conferences, and battle lines drawn in the sand.  We may think we are winning, because at least we have a plain old sundae that we have been getting year after year and its… well ….ok.  Unfortunately, under the current system, we never think of ever expecting something better.   We are too afraid that we might lose what little we have that we forgo a much better opportunity or some much desired whipped cream on our HOT FUDGE sundae.

Honestly, I have had far greater success with my daughter’s teachers when I take all emphasis off the IEP, and give them the ability to be creative.    Now you may be yelling…”But you have got a better school system than I do.”  Not true.  Yes, I do have a good school system, but they get better and better every year my daughter is there, because I give them freedom – which completely contradicts the purpose of an IEP.  I also believe there are good teachers everywhere, and from my experience tutoring in an inner city school, they are there too.  Unfortunately, they are just bogged down by even more rules than we find in the suburbs, courtesy of some well meaning bureaucrat.

Your experience is what you decide to make of it.  You can choose to argue over every little issue that comes up, or you can try a different approach where you give up all the “faux” control you think you have.    What makes my experience so different than many of the families I talk to, is that  I took the government and the legalities (i.e. red tape) out of my daughter’s education and set her teachers free to flourish in an environment where they don’t feel they need to have a lawyer in the other room.  I let them practice their art.

You may think that you will be taken advantage of, but if we ever hope to change the status quo, and the indoctrination we have received to “scream til we get what we want”, things will never change.   We are decades out from IDEA, and our schools are now trained in defense, so we have to take the first step and trust that the schools  will answer our call to think differently about the education of children with disabilities.  The government will never be able to MAKE this happen.

  1. Becky Beaubien
    February 23, 2011 at 7:45 am

    Encouraging blog…although I am interested in the specific details of how you are accomplishing this goal. You see, I feel like we have the whipped cream topping right now in preschool. Sometimes, I feel this may not last long but I still continue to dream. We had our first IEP meeting last year, and the entire focus was just getting her speech therapy…nothing else. People thought I was crazy. I was told that in the future I needed to know my laws better because my only protection is the words in the IEP. I often hate hearing that because I feel it sets up a mentality of “us verse them, ” and I do not like that. I want a team…a happy team, not a divided one with each of us working to simply protect ourselves. So, as we head to our second IEP soon I am encouraged because our speech therapist said it will be simple…carry on with her speech services. Kristen’s preschool has never seen her IEP because I have intentionally made it that way. I have given them the freedom to do what they think is best for Kristen with no restraints. I will be the first to speak up if I see a problem, but giving them that freedom has made a wonderful team and learning environment for Kristen. It, so far, has been better than I could have ever imagined. According to what you say, I can keep striving for the whipped cream even in the school years ahead and dealing with the dreaded IEP. I will continue to dream big…

    Reply
    • Valerie Strohl
      February 23, 2011 at 9:31 am

      You are right – you need to continue to DREAM BIG. I think that what happens to parents is that they lose their steam. Every year your child progresses in school, the system wants to exclude them more and more- and you begin to cross your dreams off the list . Honestly, I don’t think schools have bad motives, I think this whole thing of Special Education continues to evolve. But if we are not careful – it will stay where it is – which is unacceptable.

      Special education segregates students with different learning styles – period. What are our motives in doing this? Extra attention? Well yes, but we assume that our kids don’t pick up pieces in a gen ed classroom. My experience simply does not support the notion that these kids need to be pulled out – that is an old way of thinking.

      This is why I become so discouraged with developmental preschool. We are starting this process of segregating children at age 3. For the majority of 3 yr olds, this is simply unnecessary, and our daughters prove this. Unfortunately, the schools have decided in a one size fits all approach and the approach is for a worse case scenario.

      So, instead of getting angry and yelling, we need to guide and demonstrate our willingness to help schools bring what we want for our child’s day. My daughter’s IEP is coming up in April. We have taken the meeting out of the sterile conference room and I am bringing some good snacks and drinks, because these people are staying after their work day and they deserve a little love. I have already prefaced in an email that I want to do this differently and what I hope to accomplish during our little “chat” (notice the omission of Case Conference). Goals need to move away from systemic measurements to quality of their day. Who cares if your daughter can capitalize the first word in a sentence if no one will ever see the sentence because she is excluded from her community.

      What we have to do is start to have quality conversations, because in the end, I believe schools and parents want the same thing. We just need to start a new and less hostile conversation. There is much truth to the statement “you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar”. I intend to live by this.

      Reply
  2. Anonymous
    February 23, 2011 at 9:03 am

    Experience is a teachable moment if we make it a learning experience instead of a crutch to excuse failure. Thanks for reminding us to share the whipped cream!

    Reply
    • Valerie Strohl
      February 23, 2011 at 9:32 am

      Thanks Anonymous! I hope you are a teacher! Thanks for all the whipped cream you want to give so badly!

      Reply

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *